GDX VS PHYS
4 min read
By Ron Koren, ETF Insider

GDX VS PHYS

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) have become an integral part of modern investment portfolios, providing investors with an efficient way to diversify their holdings across various sectors and asset classes. In this article, we will conduct a comprehensive comparison between two prominent ETFs: GDX (VanEck Vectors Gold Miners ETF) and PHYS (Sprott Physical Gold Trust). By examining their ETF tickers, full names, issuers, sectors, top holdings, capitalization, strategy, tracking methods, and exposure, we aim to shed light on the distinctions between these two investment options.

GDX Vs PHYS: Overview

GDX and PHYS are two ETFs that offer distinct approaches to investing in the precious metals sector. While GDX focuses on the gold mining industry, PHYS is designed to provide exposure to physical gold. This fundamental difference in strategy results in varying risk profiles and potential returns, making it crucial for investors to understand the nuances of each ETF.

GDX Vs PHYS: Sectors and Top Holdings

GDX primarily invests in companies engaged in gold mining activities, such as extraction, production, and exploration. The ETF's top holdings often include leading players in the industry, like Newmont Corporation and Barrick Gold Corporation. In contrast, PHYS stands out by offering direct exposure to physical gold bullion, held in secure vaults. The choice between investing in gold mining stocks or holding physical gold has implications for diversification and risk management within an investment portfolio.

GDX  overlap GDX VS PHYSGDX overlap GDX VS PHYS

GDX Vs PHYS: Capitalization and Strategy

GDX, being one of the largest gold mining ETFs, commands a significant asset under management (AUM), reflecting its popularity among investors seeking exposure to the gold mining sector. The ETF's strategy revolves around capturing the performance of gold mining companies, which can be influenced by factors such as production costs, geopolitical stability, and global gold demand. On the other hand, PHYS's strategy is centered around holding and providing exposure to physical gold, capitalizing on changes in the price of the precious metal itself.

GDX Vs PHYS: Tracking and Exposure

GDX's performance is closely tied to the performance of gold mining companies, making it susceptible to factors that affect the broader mining industry. The ETF tracks an index of gold mining stocks, aiming to replicate the index's returns. PHYS, in contrast, seeks to track the price of physical gold by holding gold bullion in a secure storage facility. This difference in tracking methods results in varying responses to market movements and economic conditions.

Conclusion

In the world of ETF investing, GDX and PHYS represent two different ways to gain exposure to the gold sector. GDX focuses on the performance of gold mining companies, while PHYS provides a direct link to the price of physical gold. As investors evaluate their options, it's crucial to consider factors such as risk tolerance, investment goals, and overall portfolio diversification. For those seeking a more comprehensive understanding of these ETFs and other financial instruments, ETF Insider offers a user-friendly app that provides insights into holdings, correlations, and overlaps.

<span style="color:gray; font-style:italic;">Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not provide investment advisory services.</span>

Sources:
VanEck Vectors Gold Miners ETF (GDX) Fact Sheet
Sprott Physical Gold Trust (PHYS) Overview
Bloomberg ETF Screener
Investopedia: Understanding the Gold ETF

Get started

FAQ

  • Why is GDX better than PHYS?

    GDX may be considered better than PHYS for some investors due to its specific focus, offering diversification.

  • Does PHYS beat GDX?

    PHYS's performance relative to GDX will vary over time, depending on market conditions.

  • Should I invest in GDX or PHYS?

    The choice between GDX and PHYS should align with your investment goals, risk tolerance, and desired exposure.

  • Are GDX and PHYS good investments?

    Both GDX and PHYS can be suitable investments depending on individual investment strategies, goals, and risk profiles.

  • What is the correlation between GDX and PHYS?

    The correlation between GDX and PHYS can vary over time, reflecting differences in performance.