4 min read
By Ron Koren, ETF Insider


In the world of finance, it's critical to make informed decisions, especially when it comes to investing in ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds). Two ETFs that are constantly being compared are GSG and DBC. Both have garnered attention for their market performance and strategy, but which one is right for you? In this article, we will dig deep into the main differences between the two to help you determine your best investment choice.

GSG VS DBC: Sectors and Top Holdings

At the heart of every ETF are its underlying holdings. The sectors and top holdings give insight into where the fund is putting its money and can determine the risk and reward ratio.
GSG: Primarily focused on the energy sector, GSG's top holdings tend to gravitate towards oil, natural gas, and related commodities. This means GSG can be more sensitive to global energy market dynamics and prices.
DBC: On the other hand, DBC is more diversified. While it also has significant holdings in the energy sector, it extends its reach to agriculture, metals, and other commodities. This diversity can make DBC a bit more stable in terms of its exposure to market fluctuations.

GSG overlap GSG VS DBCGSG overlap GSG VS DBC

GSG VS DBC: Capitalization strategy

Capitalization strategy reveals how an ETF weighs its holdings, giving insights into its investment approach.
GSG: Adopts a strategy that is more in line with market capitalization, meaning it will have a higher concentration of its assets in larger, more established commodities.
DBC: This fund uses an optimized strategy, which attempts to minimize risks associated with futures markets, like contango and backwardation. This means that while DBC may not always follow the market capitalization closely, it aims to provide more stable returns over time.

GSG VS DBC: Tracking and Exposure

Tracking efficiency and exposure are key factors that determine how closely an ETF follows its benchmark and how it manages risk.
GSG: Typically, GSG has shown a consistent ability to closely track its benchmark. Its main exposure is to energy commodities, making it a suitable choice for those who believe in the upward momentum of the energy sector.
DBC: With its diversified portfolio, DBC offers broader exposure to the commodities market. It has historically shown a slight tracking error, mainly because of its optimization strategy, which sometimes prioritizes risk management over tracking precision.


In the battle of GSG VS DBC, the choice boils down to your investment goals and risk appetite. If you are looking for a more focused exposure to the energy sector, GSG might be your pick. However, if you value diversification and a strategy aimed at minimizing specific market risks, DBC may be the more suitable option.
In either case, it's crucial to do thorough research and possibly consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions. Both ETFs have their merits and can be valuable additions to a diversified portfolio, depending on individual goals and market outlook.


  1. Investment Company Institute
  2. ETF Database
  3. Morningstar

GSG ETF issuer
GSG ETF official page

GSG quote and analysis

Discover the top holdings, correlations, and overlaps of ETFs using our visualization tool.
Our app allows you to build and track your portfolio.
To learn more about the GSG iShares S&P GSCI Commodity Indexed Trust, access our dedicated page now.

Get started